Lodge + Dine announces a 5-star rating for The Nantucket Tap Room after a day visit evaluating the guest experience. The restaurant excelled distinctively in its historical tavern ambiance, signature New England-inspired menu, and attentive and knowledgeable staff.
Set in the heart of New England, The Nantucket Tap Room radiates charm as a year-round tavern with deep roots in the community. Renowned for its culinary excellence, the restaurant specializes in steak, seafood, and classic pub dishes, capturing the essence of both upscale dining and a comfortable, historical tavern setting.
Inside, the restaurant exudes a cozy, rustic charm, with wooden beams and understated nautical decor that reflect the rich history of Nantucket. Light spills in from large windows, casting a warm glow over the dark wood furnishings, creating an ambiance that is both intimate and relaxed. The patio area offers a delightful contrast; surrounded by lush greenery, it’s an ideal setting for outdoor dining, blending comfort with a vibrant outdoor experience. The patio transforms as evening falls, with soft lighting and cozy warmth, inviting diners to enjoy their meal under the open sky.
The menu, inspired by classic New England flavors with Mediterranean touches, showcases an array of thoughtfully prepared dishes that highlight the use of quality ingredients. Starters include the Nantucket Clam Chowder, a rich and creamy chowder that combines smoky bacon with tender clams, offering a delightful introduction to the meal. Another notable appetizer, the Escargot, brings a taste of Burgundy to Nantucket with its garlic-herb butter, chili flakes, and grilled sourdough, adding a sophisticated twist to the tavern's offerings.
For the main course, the Branzino Meunière stands out as a Mediterranean-inspired dish, with perfectly pan-seared sea bass accompanied by haricot verts almondine and a delicate lemon butter sauce, adding a light yet flavorful option to the meal. Another hearty favorite, the Beef Bourguignon, features tender red wine-braised beef over creamy horseradish mashed potatoes, with carrots and onions in a rich burgundy reduction—a comforting and robust choice for any guest.
In addition to the exceptional food, the Tap Room’s cocktail menu enhances the experience with inventive, tequila-based Mexican-inspired drinks that have become a standout at their patio bar. Each cocktail is crafted to complement the flavors of the menu, offering a unique selection that appeals to a range of tastes.
Service at this establishment is another highlight, with staff who are both attentive and knowledgeable. Guests are met with genuine warmth, and the team is quick to offer recommendations and ensure that each diner’s needs are met with a personal touch.
Ending a meal at The Nantucket Tap Room feels like completing a memorable story set in the heart of Nantucket’s vibrant dining scene. With its seamless blend of history, comfort, and culinary expertise, this establishment continues to redefine tavern dining, setting a standard of excellence that few can match.
Nantucket Series: White Elephant, Nantucket’s Premier Harborside Retreat
Nantucket Series: A Taste of Persia in Nantucket, Inside Lemon Press
Nantucket Series: Dining by the Harbor, CRU Nantucket Oyster Bar’s Fresh Seafood Experience
Nantucket Series: Island Kitchen, A Top-Notch Breakfast Spot Redefining Mornings
Nantucket Series: Ethos Wine Bar & Bistro, Farm-to-Table Dining in Historic Downtown Nantucket
Nantucket Series: Experience Coastal Elegance, Millie’s Seafood Dining with Madaket Beach Backdrop
